Concepts & Ideas · from Proxemics 002

PR agency vs in-house corporate comms: which path?

The same craft, two different jobs. What changes when you cross from the agency floor to the corporate side — from Reza Amirul’s decade on both.

5 min read · 15 May 2025 · Source: Proxemics 002

Listen & watch

The YouTube player is the source episode; the Spotify and Apple embeds open the series.

The short answer

An agency sells communications as a service to many clients; in-house corporate comms owns the reputation of one organisation from the inside. The craft rhymes, but the incentives, tempo and definition of success differ — agency teaches range and speed, corporate teaches depth and consequence.

Key takeaways

What an agency teaches you

The agency floor is a range machine. You work across industries, formats and clients in the same month, learn to sell an idea as much as make it, and move at the tempo of pitches and launches. Reza Amirul spent his early years there, and it’s where the reflexes are built: speed, breadth, and the ability to walk into any category and be useful fast.

What changes in-house

Crossing to the corporate side trades range for depth. You own one organisation’s reputation from the inside, sit closer to the business, and stay with a decision long after an agency would have moved to the next brief. Reza’s in-house years — navigating crises in pulp & paper, pharma and tobacco, then building the narrative for Traveloka’s US-listing prep — show the trade: fewer accounts, far more consequence, and a seat at the table where the risk actually lives.

Agency vs in-house: side-by-side

DimensionAgencyIn-house
ClientsManyOne
TempoFast, project-basedSustained, organisational
You ownThe pitch and the deliverableThe reputation and the consequence
BuildsRange, speed, sellingDepth, judgment, risk sense
SuccessClient retained, campaign landedReputation protected, business enabled

Frequently asked questions

Is going in-house a step down from agency?
No — it’s a step into consequence. You trade the variety of many accounts for the depth of owning one reputation end to end.
Which pays better?
It varies by market and seniority. They reward different things: agency rewards range and new business; in-house rewards judgment and staying power.
Can you move back to agency later?
Yes, and many do. The range and the depth compound either way — the strongest communicators have lived on both sides.
Watch the source episode
Proxemics 002 — Big Pharma, Big Tobacco & the birth of Iluminar
Full show notes, people, and transcript →
By the White Wood editorial desk · Produced by White Wood for Proxemics · An exploratory explainer extending Proxemics episode 002.