Concepts & Ideas · from Proxemics 026

AI vs taste: why judgment is the new creative currency

When anyone can generate a thousand options, the scarce skill isn’t making — it’s choosing. Why taste becomes the creative currency in an AI-saturated market.

5 min read · 10 Mar 2026 · Source: Proxemics 026
The short answer

When AI makes generation effectively free, the bottleneck moves to taste: the judgment to pick the one right option from a thousand plausible ones. Making stops being scarce; discernment becomes the currency. The creative edge shifts from who can produce to who can tell what’s good — and why.

Key takeaways

Listen & watch

The YouTube player is the source episode; the Spotify and Apple embeds open the series.

Generation is no longer the bottleneck

For most of creative history, the hard part was making the thing. AI collapses that cost: a thousand competent options appear in seconds. When production is nearly free, it stops being where value lives — the bottleneck moves downstream, to choosing.

Taste as the scarce skill

Taste is simply reliable judgment about what’s good and why. In a market flooded with competent AI output, the person who can look at a thousand options and pick the one that actually works — for this brand, this audience, this moment — holds the scarce skill.

You can train taste

Taste isn’t mystical or fixed; it’s built through exposure, critique and reps. The implication for teams is a shift in what you hire and develop for: not just the ability to produce, but the discernment to choose — because AI has made the first cheap and the second precious.

Frequently asked questions

Why does taste matter more with AI?
Because AI makes generation nearly free, so the scarce skill shifts from making options to choosing the right one — that’s taste.
What exactly is ‘taste’ here?
Reliable judgment about what’s good and why — the ability to pick the option that works for a specific brand, audience and moment.
Can taste be developed?
Yes — through exposure, critique and repetition. It’s trainable, not fixed, which is why teams should hire and develop for it.
Watch the source episode
Proxemics 026 — Apakah AI Akan Menggantikan Pekerja Kreatif? Fakta Tentang Taste & Judgement di Dunia Kreatif
Full show notes, people, and transcript →
By the White Wood editorial desk · Produced by White Wood for Proxemics · An exploratory explainer extending Proxemics episode 026.